Has retargeting really boosted your matchmaking ads?
-
I’ve been running matchmaking ads for a while now, and one thing that’s always bugged me is how quickly potential users just vanish. You spend time (and money) getting your ads in front of singles, they click, browse, maybe even start signing up—and then poof, gone. It’s like watching someone walk into your store, look around, and leave without saying a word.
That’s when I started wondering if I was missing something simple. I kept hearing other advertisers talk about “retargeting” like it was some secret trick. I wasn’t totally convinced. To me, it sounded like one of those buzzwords people throw around to sound smart. But curiosity got the better of me, so I decided to test it out myself.
The early struggle
When I first started running ads for dating and matchmaking platforms, I focused on broad targeting—trying to attract as many people as possible. Singles between 25–45, a mix of interests, clean visuals, a flirty CTA—the usual stuff. The problem? I was getting plenty of clicks but very few signups.
It was frustrating because these weren’t low-quality ads. The traffic looked good on paper. But people were dropping off after visiting the landing page. I didn’t know why, and that uncertainty was killing my budget.
At some point, I realized I was treating every visitor like a stranger every single time. If someone had already shown interest once, why was I ignoring them in my ad strategy? That’s when I decided to look deeper into retargeting.
My first real experiment
So I set up a small retargeting campaign. Nothing fancy—just simple ads reminding past visitors about the platform. I used visuals that connected emotionally: “Still looking for your match?” or “Someone you’d click with might be waiting.”
Within a week, I noticed something interesting. The cost per lead went down. Not dramatically, but enough to make me sit up. Then it got better—the quality of signups improved too. These weren’t random users; they were people who had already shown curiosity. Retargeting was like giving them a gentle nudge instead of shouting, “Hey, come back!”
What really surprised me was how “quiet” the growth was. There was no overnight spike, but the results built up steadily over a few weeks. My total conversions doubled without increasing my budget too much. It made me realize that not every successful ad campaign has to be loud or aggressive. Sometimes, it’s about timing and reminders.
Where it got tricky
Not everything went perfectly. At first, I overdid it with frequency. My ads started following people everywhere—Facebook, YouTube, even random blogs. A few users actually complained. That’s when I realized retargeting can backfire if you don’t set limits.
So, I started capping the frequency and shortened the time window. I focused more on “gentle reminders” than pressure ads. The goal wasn’t to stalk people—it was to re-engage them when they were ready.
It helped to personalize the message a bit too. Instead of showing the same ad to everyone, I created small audience segments: one for users who visited the homepage, another for those who almost finished signing up, and another for people who viewed profiles but didn’t message anyone. The more relevant the ad, the better it performed.
What I learned
Retargeting doesn’t feel like a flashy marketing hack anymore. It’s more like an ongoing conversation with people who already care—just not enough yet.
For matchmaking ads, it’s especially powerful because decisions about dating aren’t instant. People hesitate, think, compare, or wait for the right moment. Retargeting keeps your platform in their mind until they’re ready to take the next step.
If you’re on the fence about trying it, I’d say start small. You don’t need fancy tools or a huge budget. Just set up a basic campaign targeting users who’ve already engaged with your site or app. See how they respond. You’ll probably notice, like I did, that conversions start to creep up quietly but consistently.
Here’s the post that actually helped me understand the concept better:
How Retargeting Drives Growth for Matchmaking Ads?
Final thought
If I had to sum it up, I’d say retargeting turned my ad campaigns from “hope they come back” to “let’s gently remind them why they showed interest.” It’s not a magic button, but it feels like giving your ads a second chance to connect.
So yes, retargeting quietly drives growth—it’s just not the kind of growth you notice in a single day. It builds momentum, quietly and effectively, until one day you realize you’re not chasing users anymore—they’re coming back on their own.